Guides 7 min read

Best AI SEO, AEO and GEO Agencies for Small Businesses (2026): Prices Compared

For most small businesses the realistic AI SEO shortlist is FirstIndex ($2,000/month, software only), SuperDupr ($297/month local or a $5,000 build), Flying Cat (from $4,000/month) and RevenueZen (from $3,000/month). Nine agencies compared by published price, who they're built for and who each is best for.

JM
Justin McKelvey
November 19, 2026

What are the best AI SEO, AEO and GEO agencies for small businesses?

For most small businesses, the realistic shortlist is FirstIndex ($2,000 a month, software companies only), SuperDupr (free check, $1,500 audit, $5,000 build, or $297 a month for local service businesses), Flying Cat (from $4,000 a month, B2B SaaS) and RevenueZen (from $3,000 a month). The agencies that show up most often when you ask ChatGPT for "the best AEO agency", like Omniscient Digital, First Page Sage, Graphite, Directive and Grow and Convert, are strong, but they're built for funded software companies with budgets of $10,000 a month or more.

Disclosure: SuperDupr publishes this list and is on it. We kept our own entry to the same facts as everyone else's, and every price below was read from each agency's own website on November 18, 2026. Where an agency doesn't publish a price, we say so.

AEO (answer engine optimization), GEO (generative engine optimization) and AI SEO mean the same goal: getting your business named when someone asks ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude or Google's AI who to hire or what to buy.

Which AI SEO companies publish their prices?

AgencyPublished price (read 11/18/2026)Built forBest for
SuperDuprFree AI Visibility Check; $1,500 audit; $5,000 build plus optional $500/month; Local AI Search $297/monthSmall and mid-size businesses, local service businessesSmall businesses that want a fixed price and the real AI answers shown before and after
FirstIndex$2,000/month (3-month start, then month to month), $1,500/month on 12 months; $1,000 one-time reportSoftware companies on Next.js, Astro, React Router or RailsSmall software companies that want a done-for-you plan at a flat price
RevenueZenSix plans, from $3,000/month (Foundation) to above $10,000/month (Enterprise)B2B companiesTeams that want a set number of new and refreshed pages each month
Flying CatEngagements start at $4,000/monthB2B SaaSSaaS teams selling in more than one language or market
Grow and ConvertStarting at $10,000/monthCompanies that sell through contentTeams that measure content by leads, not traffic
Omniscient DigitalFull-service engagements start at $120,000/yearB2B softwareLarger B2B software companies
First Page SageNot publishedB2B, SaaS, cybersecurity, fintech, e-commerceCompanies in its listed industries that want a long-tenured firm
GraphiteNot publishedGrowth-stage tech companiesSoftware companies that want research-driven AEO and SEO
DirectiveNot publishedB2B brandsB2B companies that want AI search inside a full marketing agency

What does each agency actually do?

SuperDupr

SuperDupr is our agency, run by Justin McKelvey. The work is sold as fixed-price steps: a free AI Visibility Check for local businesses, a $1,500 AI Search Audit Justin does personally, a $5,000 build delivered in 3 to 4 weeks with optional $500 a month monitoring, and Local AI Search at $297 a month for local service businesses. We work on WordPress, Webflow and custom-coded sites. The limit: we're a small team, so this isn't a fit if you need a large content team writing 20 articles a month.

FirstIndex

FirstIndex, run by Josh Pigford, sells one plan at $2,000 a month: up to 12 in-depth articles, 50+ fixes to existing pages, comparison pages and free tools, index checks, directory listings, 5 outreach pitches and a weekly report. It reports the share of buyer questions where ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude or Google AI Mode names you. It works only with software companies on Next.js, Astro, React Router or Rails; its site lists WordPress, Webflow and Framer as not a fit yet.

RevenueZen

RevenueZen publishes six plans. The $3,000 Foundation plan includes 4 new pages and 3 refreshed pages a month with a monthly report and call; higher plans add more pages, backlinks and Reddit work, up to Scale at $10,000 a month and Enterprise above that. It's one of the few agencies that shows exactly what each price buys.

Flying Cat

Flying Cat is a founder-led SEO and GEO consultancy for B2B SaaS, working in English, French, German, Italian and Spanish. Engagements start at $4,000 a month. It says it took D2L's share of AI answers from 12% to 33% with demo requests up 73%, and lists itself as a Clutch Global winner for fall 2026.

Grow and Convert

Grow and Convert is a content-focused SEO and GEO agency. Its SEO and GEO service starts at $10,000 a month, and its pitch is content written to convert, measured by leads rather than traffic.

Omniscient Digital

Omniscient Digital is an Austin-based organic growth agency for B2B software companies, covering SEO, GEO and content. Full-service engagements start at $120,000 a year, which puts it out of reach for most small businesses.

First Page Sage, Graphite and Directive

All three are large, well-known firms that don't publish prices. First Page Sage has 15+ years in SEO and runs separate AEO and GEO services with industry pages for B2B SaaS, cybersecurity, fintech and e-commerce. Graphite is a research-driven growth agency that names Webflow, n8n and Hinge Health as clients. Directive is a B2B marketing agency that says it has 130+ strategists and has served 700+ brands. Expect custom quotes sized for funded companies.

What are the best GEO agencies?

Most agencies on this list sell GEO (generative engine optimization) under that name or one of its cousins. The ones that call it GEO on their own sites: Flying Cat (an "SEO and GEO" consultancy for B2B SaaS, from $4,000 a month), Grow and Convert (an "SEO and GEO" service from $10,000 a month), Omniscient Digital (SEO, GEO and content for B2B software, from $120,000 a year) and First Page Sage (a separate GEO service, price not published). FirstIndex doesn't use the word but does the same work at $2,000 a month for software companies. SuperDupr's GEO work is described on our GEO agency page, at the same prices as the rest of our AI search services.

The name matters less than the scope. Ask each one which AI tools they'll track (ChatGPT, Perplexity, Gemini, Claude, Google's AI Overviews), how many buyer questions, and how often.

Which is the best AI SEO agency for a small business?

If you are...Look at
A local service business (plumber, roofer, med spa, law office)SuperDupr Local AI Search at $297/month, after the free check
A small software company on a modern code stackFirstIndex at $2,000/month
A professional firm or small business that wants to know what's wrong firstA one-time audit: SuperDupr's $1,500 or FirstIndex's $1,000 report (software only)
A B2B SaaS company with $4,000+ a month to spendFlying Cat or RevenueZen
A funded software company with $10,000+ a monthGrow and Convert, Omniscient Digital, Graphite, First Page Sage or Directive

How should you compare AI SEO companies?

Ask every agency the same five questions. Which buyer questions will you track, and in which assistants? Can I see a sample report with the real AI answers in it? Who writes the pages and checks the facts? What do you do off my site, like reviews, directories and best-of lists? What happens to the work if I stop? Our longer guide on how to choose an SEO or AEO agency covers the red flags, and what AEO agencies cost breaks down the rate cards.

Be wary of any agency that guarantees ChatGPT will recommend you. Nobody controls what a model says. A good agency shows you the answers before and after instead.

Do you need an agency, or would a tool do?

The top solutions for AI visibility and generative engine optimization come in two kinds: tools that measure where AI answers name you, and agencies that do the fixing. Tool prices read from each vendor's page on November 18, 2026:

ToolPriceWhat you get
Otterly.aiFrom $29/month20 tracked questions on 3 of its 7 AI engines, checked daily
LLMrefs$79/month500 tracked questions across all AI engines, weekly reports
Peec AIFrom $95/month50 tracked questions on 3 AI models, checked daily
Scrunch$250/monthTracking plus site audits
ProfoundCustom (enterprise only)The deepest coverage, for large brands

If you have someone on staff who can write and edit pages, a tracking tool can be enough: it shows which AI answers name you, and your team makes the fixes. Justin compared the tracking tools in the best AI visibility tools. If nobody has the time, that's when an agency pays for itself. Our AI SEO agency and AEO agency pages show what we'd do for you.

Sources

Read November 18, 2026: firstindex.com and firstindex.com/pricing; revenuezen.com/pricing; flyingcatmarketing.com and its GEO and AEO service page; growandconvert.com/seo-geo-service; beomniscient.com; firstpagesage.com and its AEO services page; graphite.io; directiveconsulting.com. Prices change; check each agency's page before you buy.

Frequently Asked Questions

SEO AI Search
Justin McKelvey

Written by

Former CTO at an AI startup and former Head of Product, with 50+ products shipped. I ran snowboard and bike shops before I taught myself to code, so I build AI systems and websites with the owner in mind.

The Service Business AI Brief

The Service Business AI Brief — one practical AI win for service businesses, every other week. No fluff, unsubscribe anytime.

Ready to Implement AI in Your Business?

Book a free strategy session to see how the concepts in this article can work for your specific business.